Stonewall Movie Erases Trans Women And Black Drag Queens From History

Stonewallfilm

Ask most people who are a part of the LGBT+ community and they will have heard of the phrase Stonewall.  Some will conjure images of the Stonewall organisation, but most will be aware of the historical Stonewall Riots after which the organisation is named.

The Stonewall riots were a series of violent protests against the police by the LGBT+ community in New York in 1969.  Many cite the Stonewall Riots as the single most important event that led to the LGBT+ liberation movement in America, and the foundation upon which all modern LGBT+ rights are founded upon.

The Stonewall Riots have become so recognised as the pivotal LGBT+ equal rights event that in 2013 American President Barack Obama used it in the same sentence as Seneca Falls and Selma, two major points in history for female rights and black rights respectively.

With Stonewall being such a major part of the LGBT+ struggle, and a major piece of modern history it was inevitable that a film about that struggle would be made, especially when LGBT+ rights are such an important battlefield in todays society.

As such today we were given the first full trailer for the film ‘Stonewall’, from Hollywood director Roland Emmerich.

Now, some of you might be excited by that trailer, some of you might be looking forward to seeing the film, but some of you might be quite angry too.  To those that are unaware there is some level of controversy regarding Emmerich’s version of historical events.

The trailer, claiming to be a ‘true story’, tells the audience that a young, white, cisgender, gay man was the first to throw a brick and start the Stonewall Riots.  In truth, real historical truth based on hundreds of eye witness accounts and documented evidence that Roland Emmerich seems to have completely skipped over or simply ignored, the riots were started by black drag queens and transgender women.

Yep, sorry eager film audiences but you’re waiting to watch a lie.  The film that is being depicted as the historical telling of one of the most important moments in LGBT+ history is completely fictitious.  Yes, the riot actually happened, that’s not made up, but everything else in this film appears to be.

stonewall

The two people most credited with sparking the riots and paving the way for modern LGBT+ rights were Marsha P.Johnson, a black drag queen, and Silvia Rivera, a Puerto Rican transgender woman.  It was not a cisgender, white, gay man named Danny.  The two people who are universally recognised as starting the riots aren’t even in the film!

For those of you who might not think that it’s such a big deal, that it’s just Hollywood tweaking a story to make it work on film a little better, shut the hell up!  It is important.  If you went to see the film Selma and they’d cut out Martin Luther King Jr. and instead had the march being led by Mickey Rourke you’d probably think that there’s something wrong there.

Changing history like that is wrong.  Hollywood and Roland Emmerich are trying to take away the accomplishments of these two women, and others like them, and give it to white men, yet again.  Not only is it historically innacurate but its totally god damn disrespectful.

This film is a slap in the face to the people who took part in the riots, who fought in the streets for your right to be treated like a human being.  It’s an insult to the LGBT+ community, to trans people, to drag queens, to women and people of colour.  Hollywood have taken our moment of major historical significance and told us that the only way people will care is with a white man as the hero, that the only way change really happens is if a white man fights for it.  Hollywood’s hero complex at its absolute worst.

Do not support this film, do not promote it, advise it or even go and see it.  It’s a whitewashing, tranphobic piece of cinema that wants to crap on an important historical moment.

Amy.

xx

Follow Amy on Twitter

Join Amy on Facebook

Add Amy on Tumblr

Join Her Fans on Facebook

Facebook Comments

50 Responses to Stonewall Movie Erases Trans Women And Black Drag Queens From History

  1. Pingback: Roland Emmerich's 'Stonewall' Has A White/Cis Hero, And That's A Problem

  2. Pingback: ¿Cómo pueden grabar Stonewall sin personas transexuales? | El Príncipe Lila

  3. Pingback: Historically Accurate Stonewall Film Needs Support - Planet Transgender | Planet Transgender

  4. Pingback: This film leaves out trans activists, highlighting an epidemic in communal activism and American culture -

  5. Pingback: "Stonewall" Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead - Buzz And Gossip - Buzz And Gossip

  6. Pingback: “Stonewall” Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead | POPFIX - #Celebrity, #Tech, #Sports News

  7. Pingback: "Stonewall" Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their Whit ... | BUVit

  8. Pingback: “Stonewall” Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead | SaltyPepper

  9. Pingback: Interesting Links for 07-08-2015 | Made from Truth and Lies

  10. Pingback: "Stonewall" Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead |

  11. Pingback: The Great Gay Saviour | The Incidental Review

  12. Pingback: "Stonewall" Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead « CauseHub

  13. Pingback: “Stonewall” Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead | CZAAL

  14. Pingback: Made-in-Montreal ‘Stonewall’ slammed by LGBT activists | Pop Goes The News

  15. Pingback: July: Trainwreck | Kaitlyn Plyley

  16. Pingback: "Stonewall" Filmmakers Respond To Uproar Over Their White Cisgender Male Lead | GotOneFlix

  17. Pingback: Polémique autour du film «Stonewall»: pourquoi un appel au boycott a-t-il été lancé? | Yagg

  18. Pingback: It's Okay to Be Gay, So Long As You're WhiteUpdates News | Updates News

  19. Pingback: It's Okay to Be Gay, So Long As You're White | NigerianNation World News

  20. Pingback: It's Okay to Be Gay, So Long As You're White « CauseHub

  21. Pingback: It's Okay to Be Gay, So Long As You're White | Gay Denver and All of Gay Colorado

  22. Pingback: Squirrels Look Out For Flying Nuts and More Nuts and More Nuts… August 11, 2015 » Where the nuts chase the squirrels | Where the nuts chase the squirrels

  23. Pingback: Whitewashing e dintorni. Stonewall sbiancata e riscritta da Hollywood – Al di là del Buco

  24. Pingback: This Film Leaves Out Trans Activists, Highlighting an Epidemic in Communal Activism and American Culture | Interesting News

  25. Pingback: This Film Leaves Out Trans Activists, Highlighting an Epidemic in Communal Activism and American Culture - AltoSky - AltoSky

  26. Pingback: This Film Leaves Out Trans Activists, Highlighting an Epidemic in Communal Activism and American Culture « CauseHub

  27. Pingback: This Film Leaves Out Trans Activists, Highlighting an Epidemic in Communal Activism and American Culture | Abstrakradio.com

  28. Pingback: Squirrels Look Out For Flying Nuts and More Nuts and More Nuts… August 12, 2015 » Where the nuts chase the squirrels | Where the nuts chase the squirrels

  29. Pingback: There's a simple reason why the Stonewall trailer doesn't feature more 'trans women of colour' - Spectator Blogs

  30. Pingback: Documenting Black Queer History of the 20th CenturyUpdates News | Updates News

  31. Pingback: Documenting Black Queer History of the 20th Century | UR News Network

  32. Pingback: Transgender teens, suicide, and the media | selkindblog

  33. Pingback: Are the LG and BT Parting Ways?: A Look Into 2016 and the Focus of Unity – The MediaSen Group