ADF calls for judge’s recusal in cisgender runner lawsuit

Judge Chatigny angered ADF attorneys by asking them not to misgender the defendants in respect of science and for the sake of human decency.


Cisgender High School student Chelsea Mitchell (Left) digs it out to win against the other transgender and cisgender runners to take yet another title. But for her, one loss to a trans athlete is one too many.

The Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) angry it has been required to treat the transgender defendants respectfully has asked the presiding judge to remove himself from the case.

ESPN reports that the lawyers for the four female runners who are plaintiffs in the lawsuit argue that U.S. District Court Judge Robert Chatigny showed bias during a conference call last month when he ordered them to use the term transgender female, which he said was “consistent with science, common practice and perhaps human decency.”

Cisgender Girl Beats the Transgender runners she’s suing but says it doesn’t change anything because “Tons of Girls Lose Every Day”.

The plaintiffs, who are represented by attorneys from the hate group Alliance Defending Freedom, contend the transgender athletes have an unfair biological advantage in athletic competition that violates Title IX, the federal law that allows girls equal educational opportunities, including in athletics.

NPR station WSHU reports that Judge Chatigny asked an attorney from the ADF not to refer to the transgender girls as male, which he said was consistent with science and human decency. Attorneys for the ADF say the judge’s request destroys the appearance of impartiality in his judgment.

Judge Chatigny has not indicated when he will issue a ruling on ADF’s recusal request.

The transgender girls at the center of the lawsuit are represented by the ACLU of Connecticut.

Editor in Chief at | Website

Kelli Busey an outspoken gonzo style journalist has been writing since 2007. In 2008, she brought the Dallas Advocate on-line and has articles published by the Reconciling Ministries Network, The Transsexual Menace, The Daily Kos, Frock Magazine the TransAdvocate, the Dallas Voice and The Advocate. Kelli, an avid runner is editor in chief at Planet Transgender which she founded in 2007.

Facebook Comments

Leave a Reply